Blog posts

Fake facts & untrustworthy predictions

I need to confess to writing a misleading post some months ago entitled ‘In Einstein’s footprints?‘ on February 27th 2019, in which I promoted our 4th Workshop on the ‘Validation of Computational Mechanics Models‘ that we held last month at Guild Hall of Carpenters [Zunfthaus zur Zimmerleuten] in Zurich.  I implied that speakers at the workshop would be stepping in Einstein’s footprints when they presented their research at the workshop, because Einstein presented a paper at the same venue in 1910.  However, ...

This blog post appeared on December 4th, 2019, on

Same problems in a different language

I spent a lot of time on trains last week. ... The common thread, besides the train journeys, is the Fidelity And Credibility of Testing and Simulation (FACTS).  My research group is working on how we demonstrate the fidelity of predictions from models, how we establish trust in both predictions from computational models and measurements from experiments that are often also ‘models’ of the real world.  The issues are similar whether we are considering the structural performance of aircraft ..., the impact of agro-chemicals ..., or the performance of fusion energy and the impact of a geological disposal site ...

This blog post appeared on October 30th, 2019, on

On the trustworthiness of multi-physics models

... The process of validating computational models of engineering infrastructure is moving slowly towards establishing an internationally recognised standard...  We have guidelines that recommend approaches for different parts of the validation process...  Under the auspices of the MOTIVATE project, we are gathering experts in Zurich on November 5th, 2019 to discuss the challenges of validating multi-physics models, establishing credibility and the future use of data from experiments...

This blog post appeared on October 2nd, 2019, on

Archive video footage from EU projects
... We are in the last twelve months of the MOTIVATE project and we have started producing video clips about the technology that is being developed.  So, if you missed my presentations at the conference in the US then you can watch the videos online using the links below . We have been making videos describing the outputs of our EU project for about 20 years; so, if you want to see some vintage footage of me twenty years younger then watch a video from the INDUCE project that was active from 1998 to 2001....

MOTIVATE videos: Introduction; Industrial calibration of DIC measurements using a calibration plate or using an LCD screen

 This blog post appeared on June 5th, 2019, on
In Einstein's footprints?

... I have been involved in organising a number of workshops in Glasgow, London, Munich and Shanghai over the last decade.  The next one will be in Zurich in November 2019 in Guild Hall of Carpenters (Zunfthaus zur Zimmerleuten) where Einstein lectured in November 1910 to the Zurich Physical Society ‘On Boltzmann’s principle and some of its direct consequences‘.  Our subject will be different: ‘Validation of Computational Mechanics Models’; ...

This blog post appeared on February 27th, 2019, on

Industrial uncertainty

Last month I spent almost a week in Zurich. ... I was there for the mid-term meeting of the MOTIVATE project and to conduct some tests and demonstrations in the laboratories of our host, EMPA, the Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Science and Technology.  Two of our project partners, Dantec Dynamics GmbH based in Ulm, Germany, and the Athena Research Centre in Patras, Greece, have developed methods for quantifying the uncertainty present in measurements of deformation made in an industrial environment using digital image correlation ...

This blog post appeared on December 12th, 2018, on

Spontaneously MOTIVATEd
Some posts arise spontaneously, stimulated by something that I have read or done, while others are part of commitment to communicate on a topic related to my research... This blog post on a new validation metric and flowchart appeared on June 27th, 2018, on
Brave New World
In the brave new world of digital engineering, some engineers are attempting to conceive of a world in which experiments have become obsolete because we can rely on computational modelling to simulate engineering systems. ... This blog post on a world without experiments appeared on January 10th, 2018, on
Getting smarter
Garbage in, garbage out (GIGO) is a perennial problem in computational simulations of engineering structures... This blog post is on how predictions from the simulation have to be tested against reality in order to establish confidence. It appeared on August 2nd, 2017, on

4th Validation Workshop

After Shanghai 2011, London 2013 and Munich 2014, the Fourth International Workshop on Validation of Computational Mechanics Models was held in downtown Zurich, Switzerland, on November 5th, 2019. Keynote Speakers included Linden Harris (Airbus), Anna Pandolfi (Politecnico di Milano) and Yakov Ben-Haim (Technion).

This free of charge event in the Zunfthaus zur Zimmerleuten (Guildhall of Carpenters) was attended by some 25 people. The program included three keynote and six regular presentations and a panel discussion for each session. Lively discussions continued over the breaks and during the drink reception closing the successful event. The pdf-versions of the presentations in red can be downloaded from this site.


Session one:  Credible Models for Engineering Decision-Making

Keynote: The assessment of smarter testing for credibility and maturity
                  Linden Harris, Airbus, FR

Validation and credibility challenges in applied biology and toxicology
                  Maurice Whelan, JRC Ispra, IT

Experimental detection and quantification of crack networks for numerical simulation in heterogeneous materials using techniques based on 3D digital images
                  Yang Chen and James Marrow, University of Oxford, UK


Session two:   Validation of multi-physics models of engineering systems

Keynote: Validation of multiphysics models: from the material scale to the boundary value problem
                 Anna Pandolfi, Politecnico di Milano, IT

Validation of fluid-structure interaction simulations
                  George Lampeas, University of Patras and Athena Research Center, HE

Model Validation in the UK Nuclear Industry: A Proposed Probabilistic Metric
                  Steve Graham, National Nuclear Laboratory, UK


Session three: The Future of Experimental Data for Model Trustworthiness

Keynote: As our Island of Knowledge Grows, so Does the Shore of our Ignorance
                 Yakov Ben-Haim, Technion, IL

Using Historical Measurement Data for Validation of Engineering Simulations
                 Erwin Hack, Empa, CH

Middle-ear mechanics and sound localization in the lizard: a finite-element approach
                 Pieter Livens, University of Antwerp, BE


Steve_Graham_NNL_Validation of Computational Mechanics Models.pdf (Version 1.0)

Thumbnail Uploaded by Erwin Hack, 11/12/19 4:40 PM
1 of 14

Version 1.0

Last Updated by Erwin Hack
11/12/19 4:40 PM
Status: Approved
Download (1.1MB) Get URL.
Version History
Version Date Size  
1.0 2 Months Ago 1.1MB

Yang_Chen_Oxford_Crack-networks-in-heterogeneous-materials.pdf (Version 1.0)

Thumbnail Uploaded by Erwin Hack, 11/12/19 11:20 AM
1 of 14

Version 1.0

Last Updated by Erwin Hack
11/12/19 11:20 AM
Status: Approved
Download (4.9MB) Get URL.
Version History
Version Date Size  
1.0 2 Months Ago 4.9MB

Linden_Harris_Airbus_The-assessment-of-Smarter-Testing-for-credibility-and-maturity.pdf (Version 1.0)

Thumbnail Uploaded by Erwin Hack, 11/12/19 11:19 AM
1 of 30

Version 1.0

Last Updated by Erwin Hack
11/12/19 11:19 AM
Status: Approved
Download (3.9MB) Get URL.
Version History
Version Date Size  
1.0 2 Months Ago 3.9MB